7 Best Used Toyota Highlander Models For Reliability And Value

The Toyota Highlander has long been recognized as one of the most reliable mid-size SUVs available. Known for its practicality, spaciousness, and solid build, the Highlander is a popular choice for families and individuals alike.

If you are looking to buy used cars, especially used Toyota Highlander, it is important to know which model years stand out for reliability and overall value.

Understanding which Highlander models offer the best performance and lowest maintenance costs will help you make an informed decision when searching for a used car for sale.

Why Choose a Used Toyota Highlander?

When looking for a used Toyota Highlander, you are considering a vehicle that offers excellent resale value and a strong reputation for longevity. The Highlander is equipped with many features that families appreciate, such as ample seating, user-friendly technology, and a comfortable ride.

These attributes, combined with Toyota’s focus on safety and dependability, make the Highlander a top contender in the SUV market.

What sets the Highlander apart from other vehicles in its class is its consistent performance over time. Toyota’s commitment to quality means that their vehicles, particularly the Highlander, often perform well even with higher mileage.

While no car is completely free from issues, the Highlander is known for holding up well over the years with proper maintenance.

However, like any vehicle, some model years stand out more than others. Factors such as manufacturing updates, design improvements, and recalls play a significant role in determining the overall reliability of each generation.

This guide ranks the best used Toyota Highlander models based on reliability, value, and key factors to consider when purchasing a used model.

2007 Toyota Highlander (1st Generation)

The 2007 Toyota Highlander marks the final year of the first generation. It is widely praised for its reliability and solid performance. Though it lacks some of the modern amenities found in later models, it remains an excellent option for those seeking a dependable and affordable used car for sale.

Reliability: The 2007 Highlander has a strong reputation for being a low-maintenance vehicle. It is equipped with a 3.3-liter V6 engine, which delivers adequate power for daily driving. Maintenance costs are lower than some other mid-size SUVs, making it a solid choice for budget-conscious buyers.

The major issue to look out for is the airbag sensor recall, but overall, the 2007 model is a durable and cost-effective option.

Fuel Efficiency: With an average of 20-22 MPG, the 2007 Highlander offers decent fuel efficiency for its size. While newer models have improved in this department, the 2007 Highlander still remains competitive for its age.

2008 Toyota Highlander (2nd Generation)

The 2008 model introduces the second generation of the Toyota Highlander, marking significant improvements in terms of comfort, technology, and overall design. This model is equipped with a 3.5-liter V6 engine that provides more power than the previous generation while maintaining respectable fuel efficiency.

Reliability: The 2008 Highlander is known for its dependability and overall solid construction. It is still considered one of the best used Toyota Highlander models due to its smooth ride, low maintenance costs, and reliability.

This model year did have a recall for airbag issues, but if repairs have been made, it is a great choice for buyers looking for an affordable and reliable used vehicle.

Technology and Comfort: The 2008 model introduced features like an improved audio system, better interior materials, and increased passenger space. These upgrades make the 2008 Highlander a comfortable and modern option for families.

Additionally, the 2008 Highlander comes with Toyota's Safety Sense system, which adds peace of mind to its already solid reputation for safety.

2012 Toyota Highlander (3rd Generation)

The 2012 Toyota Highlander is an updated version of the 2010 model, with improved features and a more modern design. This model added more standard features and improved safety ratings. It is a great choice for those looking to buy a used Toyota Highlander that balances value with updated technology.

Reliability: Like its predecessor, the 2012 model is a reliable option. Toyota made improvements to the engine and suspension, making the ride even smoother and more comfortable. This model year has a reputation for being a durable vehicle with relatively low maintenance costs.

Safety Features: The 2012 Highlander comes with an advanced set of safety features, including traction control, stability control, and advanced airbags. These upgrades make it an excellent choice for families, as the vehicle has performed well in crash tests and safety evaluations.

2016 Toyota Highlander (3rd Generation)

The 2016 Toyota Highlander is part of the third generation but introduced several updates, including a new front-end design and an upgraded interior. Toyota also added more tech features to this model, including a new infotainment system, Apple CarPlay, and Android Auto compatibility.

Reliability: The 2016 Highlander is one of the most reliable used SUVs available today. It ranks highly for long-term durability and low maintenance costs. While it had some recalls related to the service brakes and wiring issues, these problems have been addressed in most models.

Fuel Efficiency: The 2016 Highlander also improved its fuel efficiency compared to earlier models, with averages of 20-22 MPG, making it a good choice for those who want a mid-size SUV with decent fuel economy.

2016 Toyota Highlander Limited

The 2016 Toyota Highlander Limited is a third-generation Highlander model that offers a blend of style, reliability, and luxury features. Known for its smooth ride and upscale interior, the 2016 Limited trim takes the Highlander’s already solid reputation and adds a layer of refinement.

Performance and Handling: The 2016 Highlander Limited is powered by a 3.5-liter V6 engine that produces 270 horsepower, paired with an eight-speed automatic transmission. This setup delivers smooth and responsive acceleration, making it suitable for both daily commutes and longer journeys.

Additionally, the 2016 Highlander Limited offers standard all-wheel drive (AWD), providing added traction for tackling various weather conditions and road types.

Interior and Features: Inside, the Highlander Limited stands out with its premium features, including leather upholstery, a power tilt-and-slide sunroof, and a JBL audio system that fills the cabin with rich sound.

The front seats are heated and ventilated, while the second-row seats are spacious and adjustable, providing comfort for passengers. Standard tech features include a 12.3-inch touchscreen with navigation, a rearview camera, and Toyota’s Safety Sense suite, which includes forward collision warning and lane departure alert.

Safety: The 2016 Highlander Limited earned high marks for its safety performance, equipped with advanced safety technologies such as blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, and parking sensors. Its impressive safety features, combined with a solid build and excellent crash-test ratings, make it a great option for families.

2016 Toyota Highlander XLE

The 2016 Toyota Highlander XLE offers a balance of luxury features and family-friendly practicality. A step up from the base models, the XLE trim adds convenience and comfort, making it a desirable option for buyers seeking a used Toyota Highlander with a premium feel without the higher price tag of the Limited trim.

Performance and Handling: The 2016 Highlander XLE comes equipped with a 3.5-liter V6 engine, which delivers 270 horsepower. Paired with an eight-speed automatic transmission, it offers smooth shifting and responsive acceleration.

While the V6 offers plenty of power, the 2016 Highlander XLE also maintains reasonable fuel efficiency, with an EPA rating of 20 MPG city and 27 MPG highway for the front-wheel-drive version.

Interior and Features: The 2016 Highlander XLE boasts a well-appointed interior, featuring high-quality materials such as leather upholstery, a power-adjustable driver’s seat, and a second-row bench seat that can accommodate up to eight passengers.

Safety and Comfort: Toyota equipped the 2016 Highlander XLE with a host of safety features, including Toyota’s Safety Sense suite, which includes pre-collision warning, adaptive cruise control, lane departure alert, and automatic high beams. The 2016 Highlander XLE offers a smooth, quiet ride with great handling and minimal road noise, making it an ideal choice for long drives and city commutes alike.

2021 Toyota Highlander XLE

The 2021 Toyota Highlander XLE is a standout in Toyota’s fourth-generation Highlander lineup. Known for its refined design and tech-savvy features, this model offers the best of modern driving in an affordable package.

With a sleek, aerodynamic exterior and a spacious, premium interior, the 2021 Highlander XLE ensures a smooth ride, packed with advanced technologies like Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and Toyota’s Safety Sense 2.5+ suite of driver-assist features.

Performance and Efficiency: The 2021 Highlander XLE comes with a powerful 3.5-liter V6 engine, offering 295 horsepower and smooth acceleration. The hybrid variant also makes a mark with its remarkable fuel efficiency, boasting an estimated 36 MPG city and 35 MPG highway.

Whether you’re running errands around town or heading out on a long road trip, the 2021 Highlander XLE ensures your family enjoys a comfortable and efficient drive.

Interior and Comfort: Inside, the 2021 Highlander XLE offers a spacious cabin with seating for up to eight passengers. Premium materials, including soft-touch surfaces and leather upholstery, provide a luxurious feel. Standard features include a 12.3-inch touchscreen, a panoramic sunroof, and a power-adjustable driver’s seat for maximum comfort.

For added convenience, the 2021 model also offers a hands-free power liftgate and second-row captain’s chairs, making it easier to access the third-row seating.

Making the Right Choice

When you are looking to buy used cars, including a used Toyota Highlander, AutoTrek is here to assist you in finding the perfect vehicle. Our wide selection of reliable used cars includes options like the used 2021 Honda Accord EX-L, the used 2021 Honda Accord LX, and the used 2014 Honda Accord EX-L V6. We offer a no-haggle, one-price guarantee, ensuring a stress-free car-buying experience.

Additionally, AutoTrek works with Colorado’s top credit unions, providing you with the best financing options available for your used car for sale.